Unless you’ve been living under a deep rock while squeezing your head the last few weeks you’ll realize that christmas time is upon us. And, as this is a religious holiday, with this comes all the dogma and specials on tv. It’s common knowledge that I hate christmas but even then I’m not anti-christmas. Nothing irritates me more than companies and people who say ‘happy holidays’ instead of ‘merry christmas’ so as to not offend. I’m an atheist who usually wears a santa hat on christmas eve and the day itself; if I can get into it then no one else has an excuse. But I digress.
I was reading an article written by british comic Ricky Gervais yesterday about why he became an atheist. I liked the way it was written, not only because I agree with him, but because I am interested as to why people come to believe what they do. I later saw that Conan O’Brian had posted a link to it in his Twitter account (see I mentioned Twitter…that’s right I’m modern) and caught quite a bit of flak for it. But I have to wonder how many people actually took the time to read the entire article and think about it before writing back.
Earlier I mentioned that I’m also an atheist, albeit I see myself as a scientist and a reasonable person willing to change my viewpoints were I to get proof to the contrary. When others have learned this I have had everything happen from being looked at with pity like I’m a lost puppy, to anger like I’m the devil, to disdain like I’m beneath them, and once in a while an interesting look and someone will whisper, “so am I.” I also can’t count the number of conversations I have had from people trying to convert me, and, as surprising as it sounds, I don’t mind them. I think that if you believe in something that strongly, then you have a responsibility to try to change my mind.
I love debate and welcome anyone who wants to have an intelligent argument about anything from religion, to the weather, to politics, to the weather affecting politics, and even on what terrible thing I would rather do if I had to. Talking about religion is fun, and high intensity, because no matter who you are talking to they strongly believe in it. The problem is, as people are attached to it, they can get hostile when you question them even though I’m not directly saying that they’re wrong (ok…in a way maybe I am but I’m willing to accept I could also be wrong.) I’ve talked with some that it has strengthened their belief; I’ve talked with some that it was weakened their belief; But no matter the end result, they are more confident and more aware in their own knowledge of the subject, and I think that is far more valuable than faith any day. This being said, I can’t count the number of conversations I’ve had that ended in the other person shouting, “Well you’re just going to hell!”
This suggests to me they are someone who has never truly examined their beliefs. These are the people who irritate me more than anything. A life unexamined is a life unlived. If you feel the way you feel about anything for no other reason than that is the way you were raised, or that is what was around you, then in short I hate you. I dislike sheep, if you are to truly feel the way you do you must think for yourself about why. I think this is what makes the converted such strong believers, the truth, as you see it, is all the more powerful if you make the discovery yourself than if it is told to you.
One of the best conversations I ever had was with my sister Wendy, we were at dinner and had a long conversation about it, with no hostility, and it made me respect her even more than I already do. She makes good arguments, they are well thought out and researched, and I can directly ask something without being shut out. At the end of our conversation that day I could tell she wasn’t done and I mentioned that I supposed we were going to have more of these talks, to which she replied yes. The only thing I could say was “good. That’s how it’s supposed to work.” I look forward to our next talk and what it brings. However, I don’t think we’ll be able to move each other off of our talking points.
But hey…I’ve been wrong before.
And because I like to hear from those who read my blog I’d like to know this: What things in life have you strengthened your belief of, or changed your position on, after a good talk with someone?
Also, if you’d like to read the article by Ricky Gervais, and I suggest that you do, follow the link below.
http://blogs.wsj.com/speakeasy/2010/12/19/a-holiday-message-from-ricky-gervais-why-im-an-atheist/